Elections 2011 - Greens Party Vote

Thursday, 1 December 2011 by Andrew McMillan

Russel_Norman_Metiria_TureiThe Greens had a fantastic election, improving on last election's 6.72% and nine seats in the house to breaking the ten precent barrier this election with 10.62%, giving them 13 MP's in the house.

There are really two factors at play with the Greens success, the strengthening of the Green brand and the diabolical performance of the Labour Party. In terms of branding, the Greens have managed to maintain their clean, green and principled guise by rigorously staying on message.

The Greens have realised that they can fly under the radar of scrutiny if they keep to a simple idealistic message. The soft vote doesn't care about scrutiny and the media won't push for answers, if the Greens stay on message; kind of like the defence mechanism of a schooling fish. But in saying that, they have to be commended for how they managed to get their message out, again their advertising and other promotional stunts worked very well.

Along with New Zealand First, the Greens were the big winners on the night. So let's take a look at the numbers. Note that the following analysis is based 2008 data and preliminary results from the 2011 election.

Biggest Party Vote by Electorate

Rank Electorate Candidate Party (%) Change
1 Wellington Central SHAW, James 26.47 n/c
2 Rongotai NORMAN, Russel 23.07 n/c
3 Dunedin North TUREI, Metiria 22.69 n/c
4 Auckland Central ROCHE, Denise 22.13 n/c
5 Port Hills BURSTON, Joseph 19.26 n/c
6 Mt Albert CLENDON, David 16.48 +1
7 Christchurch Central MOORHOUSE, David 15.78 -1
8 Te Tai Tonga LANGSBURY, Dora Roimata 15.51 +13
9 Nelson BARLOW, Aaryn 15.33 n/c
10 Ohariu HUGHES, Gareth 14.06 n/c

The first observation is that the Greens have maintained support in their last election's best performing electorates, their urban powerhouses. Wellington Central generally had a very low voter turnout (around 64%), but with the help of James Shaw, they increased the party vote from 20.62% when Sue Kedgley stood in 2008 to 26.47% this election.

Another notable standout is Dora Langsbury in the Maori seat of Te Tai Tonga, moving up 13 places with 15.51% of the party vote.

Smallest Party Vote by Electorate

Rank Electorate Candidate Party (%) Change
61 Te Atatu STEWART, Gary 6.93 -4
62 Mt Roskill GENTER, Julie Anne 6.89 -10
63 Hunua WATTS, Charmaine A 6.76 -1
64 Waikato HARPER, Cameron 6.70 -6
65 Pakuranga   6.05 -6
66 Papakura CONROY, Caroline 5.31 -1
67 Botany   4.27 n/c
68 Manurewa   4.01 n/c
69 Mangere ROSS, Todd 3.83 n/c
70 Manukau East   3.43 n/c

Mangere, Manukau East, and Manurewa are the Labour Party's powerhouse seats, featuring 1, 2, 3 respectively on Labour's top ten party vote chart. It's no surprise that the Greens suffer where Labour performs well.

New List MP Julie Anne Genter also struggled in Mt Roskill against Phil Goff, losing 10 places. Although when we look at Labour's stats, we'll see that Goff performed well, picking up 11 spots to claim 6th place on Labour's top 10.

Biggest increase in Party Vote by Electorate

Rank Electorate Candidate Party (%) Change
25 Te Tai Hauauru McDONALD, Jack Tautokai 10.98 +35
38 Ikaroa-Rawhiti   9.36 +26
44 Waiariki   8.84 +22
43 Hauraki-Waikato   9.11 +20
37 Tamaki Makaurau CURTIS, Mikaere 9.42 +19
47 Te Tai Tokerau   8.45 +14
8 Te Tai Tonga LANGSBURY, Dora Roimata 15.51 +13
14 Wigram WESLEY, Richard 12.60 +10
19 Waitaki COUTTS, Sue 11.47 +4
29 Whangarei BAZELEY, Rick 10.42 +4

Now this is a surprise, the big changes have come from the Maori seats, even where no candidates were standing. Possible reasons for the change are having a Maori as one of the co-leaders, their key policy around child poverty and New Zealand First's avoidance of the Maori seats (NZ First get reasonable support in the Maori seats but no longer stand candidates).

Maori party voters who expected the Maori party to go with Labour last election may also have shifted their support to the Greens, and of course disaffected Labour voters.

Biggest decrease in Party Vote by Electorate

Rank Electorate Candidate Party (%) Change
24 Coromandel DELAHUNTY, Catherine 11.04 -8
49 Tamaki LECKINGER, Richard 8.35 -8
52 Clutha-Southland GOLDSMITH, Rachael 8.26 -8
55 Rotorua   8.06 -9
60 Taupo McCARTHY, Zane 7.31 -9
62 Mt Roskill GENTER, Julie Anne 6.89 -10
41 New Plymouth STEEDMAN, Geoff 9.21 -11
54 Rodney MOORE, Teresa 8.12 -11
58 Taranaki-King Country MOORE, Robert 7.84 -11
53 Waimakariri KELCHER, John 8.21 -13

Interesting to see current List MP Catherine Delahunty on this list, as the Coromandel is seen as being a rather "green" electorate.

Greens Party Vote by Electorate – Full Results

Rank Electorate Candidate Party (%) Change
4 Auckland Central ROCHE, Denise 22.13 n/c
50 Bay of Plenty   8.34 -1
67 Botany   4.27 n/c
7 Christchurch Central MOORHOUSE, David 15.78 -1
18 Christchurch East MATHERS, Mojo 11.47 +1
52 Clutha-Southland GOLDSMITH, Rachael 8.26 -8
24 Coromandel DELAHUNTY, Catherine 11.04 -8
3 Dunedin North TUREI, Metiria 22.69 n/c
12 Dunedin South GALLAGHER, Shane 13.22 +1
31 East Coast MONTEITH, Darryl 10.19 n/c
59 East Coast Bays STANSFIELD, Brett 7.77 -4
22 Epsom HAY, David 11.24 +3
20 Hamilton East MARRYATT, Nick 11.37 n/c
46 Hamilton West   8.51 -1
43 Hauraki-Waikato   9.11 +20
51 Helensville ELLEY, Jeanette 8.33 -3
63 Hunua WATTS, Charmaine A 6.76 -1
17 Hutt South WALKER, Holly 11.62 -3
38 Ikaroa-Rawhiti   9.36 +26
13 Ilam GRAHAM, Kennedy 12.98 -1
56 Invercargill KENNEDY, David 8.02 -3
27 Kaikoura BROWNING, Steffan 10.76 -5
15 Mana LOGIE, Jan 12.56 -4
69 Mangere ROSS, Todd 3.83 n/c
70 Manukau East   3.43 n/c
68 Manurewa   4.01 n/c
42 Maungakiekie LAND, Tom 9.20 -4
6 Mt Albert CLENDON, David 16.48 +1
62 Mt Roskill GENTER, Julie Anne 6.89 -10
34 Napier BAILEY, Paul Edward 9.52 +3
9 Nelson BARLOW, Aaryn 15.33 n/c
16 New Lynn TOMS, Saffron 11.92 -1
41 New Plymouth STEEDMAN, Geoff 9.21 -11
28 North Shore WATSON, Pieter 10.48 -1
26 Northcote TAVA, Vernon 10.77 n/c
21 Northland EVANS, Pauline 11.36 -3
10 Ohariu HUGHES, Gareth 14.06 n/c
39 Otaki GILCHRIST, Michael 9.29 -3
65 Pakuranga   6.05 -6
32 Palmerston North TUCKER, Corrina 10.18 -4
66 Papakura CONROY, Caroline 5.31 -1
5 Port Hills BURSTON, Joseph 19.26 n/c
57 Rangitata LIGTENBERG, Gerrie 7.90 -3
40 Rangitikei BRANNIGAN, Maree 9.22 -1
33 Rimutaka WOODLEY, Tane 9.63 +1
54 Rodney MOORE, Teresa 8.12 -11
2 Rongotai NORMAN, Russel 23.07 n/c
55 Rotorua   8.06 -9
23 Selwyn SAGE, Eugenie Meryl 11.19 -6
49 Tamaki LECKINGER, Richard 8.35 -8
37 Tamaki Makaurau CURTIS, Mikaere 9.42 +19
58 Taranaki-King Country MOORE, Robert 7.84 -11
60 Taupo McCARTHY, Zane 7.31 -9
48 Tauranga McLEAN, Ian 8.36 +2
61 Te Atatu STEWART, Gary 6.93 -4
25 Te Tai Hauauru McDONALD, Jack Tautokai 10.98 +35
47 Te Tai Tokerau   8.45 +14
8 Te Tai Tonga LANGSBURY, Dora Roimata 15.51 +13
36 Tukituki MACDONALD, Jim 9.45 -4
44 Waiariki   8.84 +22
64 Waikato HARPER, Cameron 6.70 -6
53 Waimakariri KELCHER, John 8.21 -13
35 Wairarapa ROTMANN, Sea 9.51 n/c
30 Waitakere TOLLESTRUP, Steve 10.23 -1
19 Waitaki COUTTS, Sue 11.47 +4
1 Wellington Central SHAW, James 26.47 n/c
11 West Coast-Tasman HAGUE, Kevin 13.47 -3
45 Whanganui MILNES, John 8.63 -3
29 Whangarei BAZELEY, Rick 10.42 +4
14 Wigram WESLEY, Richard 12.60 +10
blog comments powered by Disqus